Search The Virtual Driver
Tagged for Your Convenience
1940 Ford Coupe 1961 F1 season 2012 Dodge Charger SRT8 2012 Ford Explorer 2012 Jeep Wrangler 2012 Toyota Camry 2012 VW Beetle 2012 VW Passat 2013 Chevys 2013 Ford Explorer 2013 Ford Focus Electric 2013 Ford Fusion review 2013 Hyundai Genesis Coupe 2013 Hyundai Sonata SE 2013 Hyundai Veloster Turbo 2013 Infiniti JX AWD 2013 Lexus ES 350 2013 Lexus GS 2013 Mercedes GLK350 2013 NAIAS 2013 Nissan Altima 2014 Audi R18 e-tron quattro 2014 Detroit Auto Show 2014 Jeep Grand Cherokee 2014 Kia Forte 2014 Kia Soul road test 2014 Lexus IS 2014 Mazda CX-5 crossover 2014 Mazda3 2014 Mercedes S-Class 2014 Mitsubishi Mirage 2014 NAIAS 2014 Toyota Corolla 2014 Toyota Corolla S 2014 Toyota Highlander 2015 Camaro 2015 Chevy Trax 2015 Chrysler 200 2015 Detroit auto show 2015 Ford F-150 2015 Ford Mustang 2015 Hyundai Sonata 2015 Kia Sorento SX 2015 Lincoln Navigator 2015 Mini Cooper 2015 Mustang 2015 Nissan Murano 2015 Porsche Cayenne 2015 Toyota Camry 2016 24 Hours of Le Mans 2016 Chevy Volt 2016 Ford Explorer Platinum 2016 Hyundai Tucson 2017 Acura NSX 2017 Ford GT adaptive cruise control affordable carbon fiber airbag technology Alan Mulally Alfa Romeo Alfa Romeo 4C ALMS AMG SLS E-Cell AP Racing Radi-CAL Apple Car ArmorAll AROnline Aston Martin Aston Martin Vulcan Aston-Martin Atlanta Motorsport Park Audi Audi bicycle Audi R18 Audi R18 e-tron quattro Austin Powers Autocade automotive fuel cells automotive porn automotive safety systems Autorama Avro Vulcan barn finds Battle of Britain Beverly Rae Kimes Big Bang Theory BMW BMW 2 Series Active Tourer BMW 3 Series BMW i3 BMW i8 BMW i8 luggage BMW M4 video BMW X4 BMW1 Series Bob Lutz BorgWarner Breitling watches Brembo British Motor Heritage Bryce Hoffman Buick Regal GS Buick Verano Cadillac ATS Cadillac CT6 Cadillac CTS Cadillac CTS-V Cadillac CUE Cadillac Racing Cadillac XTS CAFE standards Camaro Z28 Camaro ZL1 Car Spy book Carroll Shelby Cars in Context Television Cars in Context TV Caterham Caterham Seven Center for Automotive Research CES Chapparal 2X VGT comncept Chevy Cruze diesel Chevy Sonic Chevy Volt Chicago Auto Show China Auto 2012 Chip Foose Chrysler Clarion C-Max Hybrid CNG Cobra Jet Mustang Controlled Power Technologies cork surfboard Corvette C7 Corvette C8 Corvette sinkhole Craftsman CTX tractors Dale Jr Dallara GP2 hillclimb Dan Gurney Dan Wheldon De Lorean Derek Warwick Detroit Auto Show Detroit Electric diesel engine Dodge Dodge Avenger Dodge Challenger Dodge Dart GT domestic energy donuts drag racing DRB-Hicom driver alert Ducati Ducati 899 Panigale Ducati Monster Ducati Museum Ducati Testastretta Eagle GB Eddie Rickenbacker Edsel Ford electric bike electric vehicles EPA Evanta F-150 SuperCrew federal bureaucracy Federal-Mogul Ferrari Ferrari 488 GTB Ferrari dog kennels Ferrari F12 FEV Fiat 500 Abarth Fiat 500 furniture Fiat 500X Fiat-Chrysler Ford Ford BoxLink Ford Edge Ford Explorer Sport Ford F-150 EcoBoost Ford F-150 Tremor Ford F-350 Ford Fiesta ST Ford Focus RS reveal Ford Focus ST Ford Fusion Ford GT Ford GT Mk. IV Ford Mustang Ford Mustang GT Ford S-Max Ford Transit Ford Transit Connect Formula One Formula One rules Forza Motorsport Fq hybrid braking Frankfurt Motor Show Geneva Motor Show Global RallyCross GM GM recalls Goodwood Festival of Speed Group Lotus HANS device Harley-Davidson Harley-Davidson Breakout Harley-Davidson LiveWire Harley-Davidson Seventy-Two Harley-Davidson SuperLow Harley-Davidson Switchback Haynes Owners' Workshop Manual healthcare Honda ATVs Honda endurance engine Honda motorcycles Honda Pilot Honda RA272 HondaJet hot hatch Husqvarna hybrids Hyundai Hyundai Accent Hyundai Elantra Hyundai Elantra GT Hyundai Genesis Hyundai Genesis Coupe Hyundai Veloster Indianapolis Motor Speedway Indy 500 IndyCar Infiniti Infiniti Q50 Infiniti QX56 inflatable child seat iPhone 6 J.D. Power and Associates Jabuar Jaguar Jaguar C-X16 Jaguar E-Type Jaguar F-Type Jaguar luggage Jaguar XE Jaguar XJL Jeep Cherokee Jeep concepts Jeep Renegade Jensen GT jet prropulsion Jim Clark John Krafcik Juan Manuel Fangio Kia Forte Koup SX Kia Rio Kia Sorento Kia Soul L.A. Auto Show Lamborghini Lancia Delta Integrale Land Rover LR2 Le Mans lead-acid batteries LED headlights Lego Technic book Lexus ES350 Lexus GS350 F Sport Lexus LS LExus LX 570 Lexus NX 200t F Sport Lexus RC 350 Lexus RC F Lexus RX 450h Lincoln MKC Lincoln MKX Lincoln MKZ Lincoln Motor Company Lincoln's future Lingenfelter LiquidPiston Lister Knobbly Lola LMP1 Lotus Lotus Evora 400 Lotus SUV Luca Montezemolo Lucire Lyonheart K Maserati Tipo 250F replica matte-finish film Matthew McConaughey Mazda Mazda chair Mazda Miata versus Ford Fiesta ST Mazda2 McLaren McLaren 675LT McLaren MP4-12C Spider McLaren P1 McLaren P1 interior Mercedes Mercedes 4Matic Mercedes CLA Mercedes comic book Mercedes diesel pistons Mercedes GL Mercedes GLA Mercedes GLE Coupe Mercedes pickup trucks Mercedes van Mercedes-AMG Mercedes-AMG GT Mercedes-Benz furniture metal matrix composite brakes MG wrist watch Michael Schumacher Mike Hawthorn Mini Mini Countryman Mini Coupe Mini Roadster Mini Vision Mitsubishi Mopar shaker hood muscle cars MyFord Touch NAIAS nanoslide coating NASCAR NASCAR heating scandal New Shelby GT350 New York Auto Show Niki Lauda Nissan BladeGlider Nissan Leaf Nissan Pathfinder Nissan Skyline history Nissan Smart mirror Nissan Versa Note Nnissan Quest Nurburgring OnStar FMV Pebble Beach Concours d'Elegance Peter Wright Peugeot 108 Pininfarina Pocket Classics police chases Pope Benedict XVI Porsche 917 Porsche 918 Spyder Porsche 919 steering wheel Porsche 988 Porsche P1 EV Porsche Panamera powertrain technology Prius c Prius v racing Ram Ram 1500 Ram ProMaster Ram Promaster City Range Rover rebuildable batteries Renault F1 engine Renault Twingo restomod Ricardo Engineering road repair funds Roger Penske Rolls Royce Bespoke Rolls-Royce Silver Ghost Ross Brawn Rush movie Saab safety technology Santa SBU V3 Scion FR-S Sir Malcolm Campbell Siri smart spare tires Speed sport sedans Sportster Subaru BRZ Subaru Forester Suzuki SX4 SYNC 3 Team Lotus TechShop The Aresenal of Democracy torque vectoring touchpad technology Tour de France Toyota Toyota 4Runner Toyota iRoad Toyota Prius c Toyota Tacoma Toyota Tundra Toyota Venza Toyota VenzaMcLaren MP4-12C Tracks novel Triumph Speed Triple TRW TRW touchpad U.S. Air Force Museum UAW Udvar-Hazy Center unionization vaporware Vehreo fabric Visteon Volkswagen Volvo Volvo Drive-E Volvo S60 R-Design Volvo XC90 VW VW Beetle Convertible VW Beetle TDI VW Golf VW GTI VW Jetta Hybrid VW MQB VW Passat TDI VW Touareg TDI VW troubles winter driving Xcar video XPEL Yamaha Yamaha anime Zenos E10
« Smaller Engines + More Technology = Better Economy? | Main | Ford Jumps On the Carbon Fiber Bandwagon »

An Engine In Opposition To Convention

By Christopher A. Sawyer

Achates Power CEO David Johnson.David Johnson has an enviable résumé. He launched an all-new diesel in Ford’s Super Duty pickup before heading to GM where he worked on clean diesel programs for Opel, Saab and Renault passenger vehicles. Navistar was next. There he was program manager for the MaxxPro line of Mine-Resistant Ambush-Protected (MRAP) vehicles used in Iraq and Afghanistan, before becoming vice president of product operations for military and export markets. In 2008, he went to Achates (a-kay-tees) Power as president and CEO, and was given the task of using that experience to accelerate the development of an opposed-piston two-stroke diesel engine. These engines were prevalent in the early part of the 20th century, but fell afoul of shortcomings like high hydrocarbon emissions and heavy oil consumption as that century progressed. However, until their deficits outweighed their plusses, opposed-piston two-strokes were more efficient than conventional piston motors.

“Why even bother?,” he repeats. “I asked myself the same question when I came to Achates, but the engine is very sound in terms of both physics and thermodynamics.” Not only are there no valves, there’s no valvetrain to introduce parasitic losses or add to the parts count. Also missing is a cylinder head that increases heat losses in the engine by removing temperature from the combustion chamber and releasing it to the atmosphere. Then there’s the long stroke-to-bore ratio. And the list goes on.

According to Johnson, “Many in the industry said: ‘You can’t have efficient combustion chambers in the void between the two pistons, and all two-strokes have trouble with oil consumption.’ They were historically accurate, but we believed that if we applied the engineering, materials and other improvements made to conventional engines to our motors, we could overcome these obstacles. Plus, in not knowing what couldn’t be done, we did it.” The Achates engine has demonstrated the ability to meet EPA10 and Euro6 emission standards.

Engine mounting, drive system and other features depend on the application, but canting the engine to one side is a possibility.The fuel efficiency gains versus conventional engine designs are not single-digit increases. Johnson claims gains on the order of 10%-20%. That’s significant. And that’s against the most efficient engines in the world. “Typically we show, on average, a 15% benefit,” he says. That number, it should be noted, is against four-stroke diesels of similar output. There has not been an apples-to-apples comparison to a gasoline engine, but Johnson thinks the rule-of-thumb difference would be on the order of 50%.

Achates does not have fully developed engine designs ready for production, though they are working on them with potential customers. “Based on the parts reduction and downsizing that comes with that, and a two-stroke’s greater power density per cc, our forecasts say Achates engines will be less expensive than conventional four-stroke designs,” he says. But Johnson also acknowledges that conventional two-stroke diesels fell out of favor in the 1970s when emissions regulations began to come into effect, and the four-stroke took the lead because each engine event (intake, compression, ignition, exhaust) is discrete, while a two-stroke accomplishes them in half the crankshaft time. However, he points out this was before the advent of modern microelectronics, which made controlling these events a problem, and this accelerated the shift toward four-stroke diesels.

Having opposed pistons creates an interesting problem: the pistons moved outward from the centerline of the engine, and toward the outer ends of the engine block. This suggests the Achates motor has two crankshafts. “Some of the opposed-piston engines have had two crankshafts,” says Johnson, “and some have just one. In the engines we run, we use two cranks, though we have looked at one. To us, the most important point is to have the two pistons in the one bore, and from there we do an application study to figure out which is the best engine architecture to get those piston motions converted into torque at the crankshaft.” Theoretically, it would be relatively simple to join the two cranks to a central power takeoff, but this might increase parasitic losses higher than the benefit this layout creates. “Believe me,” says Johnson, “we’ve looked at all of the possibilities, and have a number of solutions on the shelf.”

Test engines are being used to develop the concept and determine production needs.Inserting the fuel into the system is also a challenge. There are pressures, flow patterns, heating rates and other variables that must be studied to create the piston dome design, injection timing, spray pattern and more. “Since we are a diesel, we always will be direct injection,” he says. “We are not mixing the fuel and air before it enters the cylinder. We bring in the fresh air, often mixed with cooled EGR (exhaust gas recirculation), and residual exhaust gas.” That’s because, unlike a four-stroke engine, a two-stroke doesn’t fully scavenge exhaust gasses from the cylinder. The intake and exhaust ports are opened simultaneously, and exhaust gas goes out one end of the cylinder while fresh air flows in the other end. Depending on the pressure differential between the intake and exhaust ports, this determines how quickly the air flows through, how completely it is scavenged, and what remains in the cylinder as the pistons start to close off the ports. After that you have compression, the injection of the fuel and combustion.

“That’s where we have deployed computational fluid dynamics (CFD) extensively,” says Johnson, “in order to manage and understand how to make the air flow through the engine in a way that is optimized for current requirements and maximum possible efficiency.” Achates also created their own fuel lab so that they could characterize fuel spray and atomization on their own. This allowed them to tailor the atomization, droplet size, spray pattern, etc. for the engine’s combustion chamber design. “In that way,” he says, “we didn’t have to rely on a supplier industry that wasn’t very interested in opposed-piston engines.”

“We can, and have, run with multiple injections [of diesel], especially when we do studies for out light-duty [vehicle] customers. For them, noise is a critical parameter.” Nevertheless, the most efficient method is a single, optimized injection of fuel with the quickest possible burn. And when that can be done without creating undue noise or high NOx emissions from a high-temperature combustion, it is done. This makes us no different than any other engine maker in the industry,” he says. “They run the injection single-shot whenever they can.”

A lot of effort has gone into reducing the amount of work the engine has to do in order to move air into and out of the cylinders. “It really comes down to the fact that we don’t need to scavenge the cylinder after each combustion event,” claims Johnson. “Depending on where you are operating the engine, we sometimes have a significant advantage, and at other times we have a modest advantage.”

Conventional four-stroke gasoline engines are having to add technology in order to get closer and closer to diesels in terms of fuel efficiency, and Achates claims its engine is already ahead of today’s best diesels. “Because of our unique geometry, we can put multiple injectors into a single combustion chamber,” says Johnson. “There are no valves to get in the way, which makes for interesting opportunities.” Achates can add injectors around the bore as well as along the length of the bore. “We can tailor this to the fuels being used, and do things like an early injection to create a homogenous charge situation before the bulk of the fuel is introduced.”

An Achates four would have two cylinders, not four, however, friction would be a little higher due to the gear train connecting the two cranks. On the other hand, the combustion efficiency is so much higher that this offsets the higher drag. In addition, though wider than an inline or v-type engine, the Achates unit has a lower height, center of gravity, and a shorter overall length. Packaging is a plus, not a minus.

How the engine mounts in the chassis depends on the application. It can be laid down, stood on its end or anything in-between. However, it’s likely that light-duty trucks or automobiles would mount the engine flat. The fact that it is shorter in some measures and longer in others, and displaces less for the same output, means automakers might want to take a look at new ways to drop it into the vehicle. With vehicle size becoming critical to meeting future fuel economy regulations, taking a hit on vehicle width, packaging the engine partially in front of—or behind—the wheels, or even sitting it lengthwise takes care of that concern.

“The Achates engine rejects less heat, meaning radiators can be smaller. The nose can be lower, if you decide to put it up front in a conventional position. Vehicles today,” Johnson expounds, “have been optimized around the current crop of engine designs, which haven’t fundamentally changed for decades. However, that will change once a company decides it wants to embrace this technology.” Imagine the possibilities… like a four-cylinder/eight-piston mid-engined, two-stroke diesel sports car.

But what about fuels other than diesel? Is the Achates engine doomed to run on straight diesel or a mix of it and biodiesel? “I’m certain that, whatever fuels are available at the pumps of the local fuel station in 2050, they will run better and more efficiently in an Achates engine,” says Johnson. “If you can make diesel combustion work,” he continues, “you can make any fuel work.”

Every engine has a tradeoff between output and emissions, including the Achates. But as after treatment costs fall, these savings are passed along to all engines, even the opposed-piton two-stroke Achates motor. However, Johnson says that, though the fundamentals and after treatment strategies are basically the same, the greater efficiency of his company’s motor adds to the value proposition. All it takes is a vehicle maker ready to take the plunge. Just don’t expect it to happen quickly, even if the trigger was pulled today, it might take six years or more for the Achates engine to enter service; just in time for the second—tougher—half of the recently passed CAFE legislation to take effect. In the meantime, watch the skies for drones and the battlefield for vehicles powered by these engines. The military, which lives or dies on the battlefield cost of fuel, is very interested in the Achates engine.

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>